Out Darn Gaps!

In this installment, I present to you Mozzer502 (as he calls himself on Flickr).  His real name is not often used in polite company, unless of course you know him in which case you’d probably call him “Andy”.  I met Andy recently at a Star Circle Academy Workshop. He’s a hoot which is American slang for “wickedly clever” not to mention that he’s all around a fun guy who loves slinging burning steel into the ether. See his photostream to see what I mean.

I asked Andy to write up his uber cool trick for eliminating gaps in Star Trails.  Here is his work, slightly edited. Andy’s clever trick applies to star trails that are circular (i.e. revolve around the north or south celestial pole).

Dotty Problem

Now that all good discerning photographers stack their long exposure star photos, I’m sure you’ve noticed your dotty problem. I may have a solution for you for that. Take a look at these two photos. The one of the left is the original after stacking, the one on the right is the nice smooth one after processing.

Is processing a photo wrong? I won’t even bother answering that. If you think so, move along. If you want to know how to make your pictures a little less Morse Code and a little more creamy silk, read on.

We’re going to use a little used Photoshop filter called the Radial Blur. If we do this right, we’ll blur the stars just enough to fill the gaps that appeared while your camera was processing. Of course this is only going to work if we have a radial star pattern with a center we can pin.

Adobe neglected to provide a way to accurately point the radial center, so you have two options to make it work. You can start the filter and click randomly until you get it right, or you can follow this convoluted process.

Load your circular star picture. We need to make the polar star the center of the image. To do that make your window big enough to play with, select the crop tool, set the width, height and resolution to blank, and draw a crop frame. You’re trying to make a crop that has the little X in the center, right over the North Star [Editor’s note: Polaris is close enough for guv’ment work – but the actual center of rotation lies away from Polaris toward the next nearest star in the Little Dipper]. It doesn’t matter how big you enlarge your photo.

We only want to blur the stars, so the next step is to switch off all the foreground in your image. I use a combination of the magic wand, the quick selection tool, and the magnetic lasso to select the foreground and to mask it out.

When we use the blur the filter will pull data from all over your image and move it around. To ensure that the foreground doesn’t get dragged in to the stars, we’re going to next create a little more sky where the foreground used to be.  Duplicate the star layer, and nudge the lower star layer a few pixels down and to the into the space where your foreground used to be.  Just for simplicity, lets merge these two layers.

  

Now for the magic. If you’re the sort of person that likes Smart Filters, convert the layer, otherwise bring up the Radial Blur filter and set it to about 2 pixels.  For the more adventurous, play with number. If you set it to something high like 10, you get a very cool effect. It’s not realism but it is art. For this example, we’ll keep it small just to hide the trail gap.

Now all we have to do is add the foreground back in. To do this I duplicate the background, move it on top, and then use the reselect tool to create an inverse mask. Just to make the line between foreground and background believable, I like to use a 5 pixel blur on the mask.

And we’re done. At this point do your usual crop, color processing, levels and sharpening and you have a stylized silk smooth star pattern.

What if your star circle is offset or has lens distortion?

MissionPeak

All we need to do is work out how to do something like this on images that aren’t centered on the North Star. Anyone? Anyone? Bueller?

10 thoughts on “Out Darn Gaps!

  1. Olly

    This is a really creative and clever solution. I thought you might also be interested in another solution…

    The gapping problem is often caused by the camera’s long exposure noise reduction algorithm, which takes about as long to process the photo as the exposure took itself – hence the gapping.

    Most cameras have this feature automatically switched on. It guards against noise, (obviously) and also hot pixels, (where the picture exhibits unwanted red or white specks). Hot pixels appear during the exposure, after about 20-25 seconds, (depending on your camera), because the sensor heats up.

    Noise filtering can, however, be perfectly well undertaken in post production so if you want gapless pictures turn off the long exposure noise reduction. Or splash out on a camera with a super fast processor.

    Reply
    1. Steven Christenson

      Thanks for your observation Olly. If folks are following my advice they have turned off LENR (long exposure noise reduction). The gaps will still be present. The gaps will be larger when shooting east or west or when using anything but superwide lenses. Why this is so is explained in another article on my BLOG.

      It’s good to remind people however that LENR is not your friend when doing star trails!

      Reply
  2. Pingback: Stacker’s Checklist | Star Circle Academy

  3. Pingback: Poor Man’s Dark Frame | Star Circle Academy

  4. Morgan

    As for how to center on the north star when its not in the shot, create a perfect circle that nines up with any of your star trails, and then the center of that circle will the the spot to rotate around. Be sure to line up the circumference of the circle and the star trail well as a small deviation can have large effects farther from the origin. also make sure to lock the ratio of your circle as this will not work with an ellipse.

    Reply
  5. Brendan

    As for how to center on the north star when its not in the shot, create a perfect circle that nines up with any of your star trails, and then the center of that circle will the the spot to rotate around. Be sure to line up the circumference of the circle and the star trail well as a small deviation can have large effects farther from the origin. also make sure to lock the ratio of your circle as this will not work with an ellipse.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.